When you see the statistics of seven home runs, 17 runs-batted-in and a batting average of .359 compared to one homer, eight RBIs and an average of .254, it’s really easy to say the former line is much better. To identify the names behind these stats, current Philadelphia Phillies left-fielder Raul Ibanez is the former and former Phillies left-fielder and current Tampa Bay Rays designated hitter Pat Burrell is the latter.
Ibanez, who was acquired in the off-season as a free agent from the Seattle Mariners, has caused passionate Phillies fans to forget about the man who occupied left-field on a day-to-day basis for almost nine full seasons. Burrell was a former number one overall pick by the Phillies in the late-1990s and he has been a fan favorite in Philadelphia for most of his time in the City of Brotherly Love.
After the Phils won the World Series in October 2008, all the baseball fans in Philadelphia knew that Pat Burrell was to be a free agent and there was concern around the city that the Phillies organization would not re-sign him. During the winter meetings, Phillies general manager Ruben Amaro, Jr. made it clear that he was interested Raul Ibanez. Of course all the Phillies fans knew was that he played in Seattle, a team that was very rarely seen on televisions in the Philadelphia area, and that he was 36-years old, a whole three years older than Burrell.
Despite all the potential criticism, Amaro knew what a great player Ibanez was and he signed the veteran outfielder to a three-year contract. As a result, Burrell signed with the team the Phillies beat in the World Series, the Rays, and only received a two-year contract to be mainly a designated hitter.
Burrell made a couple memorable returns to Citizen’s Bank Park in the beginning of the 2009 season with an exhibition game and an emotional World Series ring ceremony. In the exhibition game as a member of the Rays, Burrell unloaded on a Cole Hamels fastball, reminding Phillies fans of what they would be missing in the upcoming 2009 season. Then in the ring ceremony, Burrell received the loudest and longest cheer from the Phillies faithful when presented with his championship ring. Pat’s ovation lasted longer than even current Phillies superstars Jimmy Rollins, Chase Utley and Ryan Howard.
But to this writer, it seems like ages ago when Pat Burrell was a member of the Phillies, in the ballpark as a member of the Rays and receiving his championship ring. Raul Ibanez has made all of the Phillies fans forget that there was any other Phillies player that played left-field in recent years. The Phils faithful has embraced Ibanez as the great player that he is. Signs in the stands at Citizen’s Bank Park read “I-BOMB-EZ” and now you can see quite a few fans wearing the number-29 Ibanez jerseys. And typical to Philadelphia, a new chant that goes “RAOOOOL” and sounds like “BOOOO” is now heard throughout the ballpark every time Ibanez steps to the plate.
There is no doubt that Raul Ibanez has won over Phillies fans with his timely hitting, solid defensive play and his hustle both in the field and on the base paths. Does anyone in Philadelphia remember the beloved Pat Burrell? I’m sure there are many who do, but Ibanez is easily causing some fans to forget.




I-BOMB-EZ!!!!! As a Phillies fan I will never forget Pat Burrell…he is a baseball icon to any Phillies fan ..however the Championship hangover has come to an end, and it is now time to look for another. With Ibanez playing the way he is, there is no doubt the Phils will be around at the end looking to repeat!
I will never forget Pat the bat, but I’ve got to admit that RAAAAAAUUUUUUUL is an upgrade!
ESPN: April Awards
Best Player with New Team: Rauuuuull I-BOMB-EZ
G 21 28
R 20 18
H 59 30
TB 57 62
2B 5 8
3B 1 0
HR 7 8
RBI 19 25
BB 11 22
SO 11 19
AVG .354 .326
SLG .695 .674
OBP .426 .452
OPS 1.121 1.126
Forgive the fact that my html skills are nonexistent. The first set of the above numbers are Raul Ibanez’s for the month of April, and the second set are Pat Burrell’s for April of last year (plus one game in March). Seems like a push to me. I think it’s a bit early to proclaim Ibanez as the man who will make “all of the Phillies fans forget that there was any other Phillies player that played left-field in recent years”.
I’m certainly not saying that Ibanez hasn’t done a solid job or that I’m not happy to have someone like him on the team I’ve followed all my life. But I think it’s far too early to anoint him the King of Left Field. Burrell’s career was far too long, and full of far too many slumps, hot streaks, boos, cheers, and a World Series championship to hand someone else the title after one short month.
As a long time Mariners fan, here’s my two cents.
Raul’s April 2009: .354/.426/.695/1.121
In August of 08: .396/.452/.703/1.154
In August of 07: .374/.447/.682/1.129
In June of 06: .326/.414/.695/1.109
He’s not going to continue this, and he’s done this every year, however timing is everything.
When Raul has his typical .218/.300/.345 or .184/.241/.262 month like last May or June 2007, Phillies fans will be missing Burrell more. Tie in the fact Ibanez is almost 37, and signed through 2011 for a pretty hefty contract, and this is a recipe for disaster.